A Girl Returned (L’Arminuta) by Donatella di Pietrantonio

Apr 7, 2025Articles, Books, Nancy0 comments

This book is a riveting story of a 13 year old girl who, after having been raised in an affluent home in the city by a couple she knew as her parents, was suddenly returned with no explanation to her poverty stricken birth family that she hadn’t even known existed.

This novel is set in central Italy in the 1960s and is based on the author’s memories of hearing about poor families with numerous children who would give one of their kids to a relative unable to have children to unofficially adopt and raise. Having known a person here in Italy who was given to an aunt to raise, I thought it would be an interesting read.

The story is quite intense as we see the girl, who remains unnamed in the book, try to make sense of what has happened, struggle to understand why her adoptive parents have rejected her, as well as try to integrate into this family who isn’t welcoming to her. At one point she says that she has two mothers but is an orphan. That statement really struck me about the importance of the mother-child relationship.  How fortunate I have been in my life to have had a mother who was committed to me as well as the privilege of being able to raise my own children!

This girl doesn’t have this good fortune, yet we see her gradual growth and resilience coming through and winning out over her circumstances.

Nancy Napier, April 2025

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Recent Posts

Welcome to the Hyunam-Dong Bookshop

Welcome to the Hyunam-Dong Bookshop

The Korean writer Hwang Bo-Reum has previously written several essay collections. This is her first novel. The book’s protagonist Yeongju did everything she was supposed to do: Go to university, marry a decent man, get a  respectable job. Then it all fell apart. Burned out, she abandons her old life, quits her high-flying career and starts to follow her dream. She opens a bookshop.

read more
The Music of Bees by Eileen Garvin

The Music of Bees by Eileen Garvin

The Music of Bees, debut novel by Eileen Garvin, is a thoughtful, life-affirming story that invites the reader to consider the healing power of community.  It is present day rural Oregon; a region dotted with fruit farms as well as other agricultural endeavors.

read more
Translate »